Artificial inflation or deflation of the price of a security
Over 1.8 million professionals use CFI to learn accounting, financial analysis, modeling and more. Start with a free account to explore 20+ always-free courses and hundreds of finance templates and cheat sheets.
Market manipulation refers to artificial inflation or deflation of the price of a security. Also known as price manipulation or stock manipulation, it involves the literal manipulation of a financial market for personal gain. It means influencing the behavior of the securities with the intent to do so.
Market manipulation can be difficult for authorities and market regulators to detect, given that multiple variables affect the price movement of a security. Some of these variables may not even be perfectly quantifiable. However, when detected, market manipulation is met with serious civil liability.
Summary
- Market manipulation refers to artificial inflation or deflation of the price of a security.
- Market manipulation can be difficult not only for authorities but also for the manipulator.
- There are two major techniques of market manipulation: pump and dump, and poop and scoop.
Why is Market Manipulation Difficult?
Market manipulation can be difficult not only for authorities but also for the manipulator. These difficulties are exacerbated by the increase in the size of the market and the number of participants in it.
Therefore, it is easier for one to manipulate the prices of the stock of a small company, like a penny stock. This is because other market participants and regulators tend to pay closer attention to companies with medium or large market capitalization.
How Does Market Manipulation Work?
There are several ways of manipulating stock prices in the market. Deflating the price of a security can be achieved by placing a significantly large amount of small order at a price that is lower than the current market price of that security.
Investors interpret it as a signal that there is something wrong with the company. A negative perception pushes investors to sell the securities, thus pushing the price of the stock even lower.
One of the ways of inflating the price of a security is by placing an equal number of buy and sell orders for the same security simultaneously, but by using different brokers. Thus, the orders cancel each other out.
The large volume of orders executed gives an investor the impression that there is an increased interest in the security. This convinces them of the possibility of future price appreciation, then they buy that security, which ultimately ends up pushing the actual stock price higher.
Techniques of Market Manipulation
Market manipulation techniques involve spreading false information via online channels that are frequently visited by investors. The barrage of bad information on message boards, when combined with market signals that seem legitimate on the surface, can encourage traders to execute a given trade.
The two major techniques of market manipulation are:
1. Pump and Dump
Pump and dump is a manipulation technique that is used frequently in order to inflate the price of security artificially. The manipulator then sells out, and followers are left with an overvalued security. This works on stocks with micro-market capitalization.
2. Poop and Scoop
The poop and scoop technique is not as frequently used as the pump and dump. Here, the price of the stock of a medium or large-cap company is artificially deflated. Once it happens, the manipulator buys the undervalued shares, thus making a profit.
Poop and scoop is rarer because it is significantly tougher to artificially affect the prices of a good company.
Currency Manipulation
This is also a type of market manipulation but is considered a different class, given that it is executed by legal authorities such as central banks and sovereign governments. Currency manipulation isn’t effectively illegal but is frowned upon and considered to be malpractice by the World Trade Organization (WTO).
Trading partners may also choose to impose sanctions on currency manipulators. Under the floating exchange rate system, countries can deflate or inflate the value of their own currency as opposed to that of other countries. They may devalue by selling government bonds or printing currency in order to make exports cheaper, and imports more expensive, thus addressing trade imbalances.
Learn More
Thank you for reading CFI’s guide on Market Manipulation. To keep learning and developing your knowledge of financial analysis, we highly recommend the additional resources below:
FAQs
If you are worried about investing a large amount of capital into long-term positions that may encounter some form of market manipulation, you can always choose to trade in the short-term with spread bets and CFDs.
Can you get in trouble for market manipulation? ›
(1) Prohibition against manipulationIt shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indirectly, to use or employ, or attempt to use or employ, in connection with any swap, or a contract of sale of any commodity in interstate commerce, or for future delivery on or subject to the rules of any registered entity, any ...
Is market manipulation scamming? ›
It's just like what it sounds. When fraudsters manipulate the market, they engage in conduct that creates an artificial price for a security, thus interfering with the free and fair operation of the market. Knowing about market manipulation can make you eligible for the SEC Whistleblower Program.
Is market manipulation ethical? ›
Market manipulation damages the interests of all investors by disrupting the smooth functioning of financial markets and lowering investor confidence. Market manipulation may lead to a lack of trust in the fairness of the capital markets, resulting in higher risk premiums and reduced investor participation.
How do you disarm manipulation? ›
8 Ways To Deal With Manipulators
- Ignore everything they do and say. ...
- Hit their center of gravity. ...
- Trust your judgment. ...
- Try not to fit in. ...
- Stop compromising. ...
- Never ask for permission. ...
- Create a greater sense of purpose. ...
- Take responsibility for yourself.
However, investors may still be able to recover their losses by filing claims in securities litigation or FINRA arbitration. If you believe that you may have lost money in a market manipulation scam or as the result of a trading violation, you should speak with a market manipulation lawyer promptly.
Is market manipulation a felony? ›
For example, 7 U.S. Code Section 13 makes it a felony punishable by a fine up to $1,000,000 and up to 10 years imprisonment to “manipulate or attempt to manipulate the price of any commodity in interstate commerce.” However, to get a conviction, the prosecutor generally must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the ...
How is market manipulation detected? ›
They also point out that, most often, prices and liquidity are elevated when the manipulator sells rather than when he buys. This shows that changes in prices, volume and volatility are the critical parameters that are to be tracked to detect manipulation.
What is the fine for market manipulation? ›
The maximum punishment for anyone found guilty of the crime of insider dealing is ten years imprisonment. No one can be imprisoned for breaching civil law, but anyone found liable of market abuse offences can face unlimited fines. The implications for any individual or organisation accused either offence are serious.
What is the most famous market manipulation? ›
The Martha Stewart case is a famous manipulation example via insider information. Stewart partook in insider trading in 2001. The CEO of an enterprise she invested in advised friends and family to sell their shares. They sold their stakes in the experimental drug Erbitux.
Generally speaking, if your matter involves the offer or sale of securities within California, it is a state law issue. If it involves more than one state, it is a federal issue. Although, it is not uncommon for someone facing criminal securities fraud to be charged on both the state and federal level.
Is market manipulation criminal? ›
Intentional cases of manipulation that have influenced the stock exchange or market price are criminal offences that are punishable by imprisonment of up to five years or a fine (section 119 (1) no.
What type of crime is market manipulation? ›
Market manipulation is another type of white-collar crime. This crime is illegal in the United States under both securities and antitrust laws.
Is painting the tape illegal? ›
Painting the tape is an illegal activity and prohibited by the SEC because it creates an artificial price.
What are the consequences of market manipulation? ›
Market manipulation can contribute to financial instability and economic uncertainty, as it distorts the allocation of resources and can lead to the formation of asset bubbles or other market disruptions.
How to detect market manipulation? ›
Price movements without news or events: Unwarranted price swings are often symptomatic of manipulative efforts. Coordinated trading activities: Detecting multiple accounts engaging in similar trading behavior often suggests collusion and market manipulation.
How to avoid market maker manipulation? ›
You could avoid pump and dumps by creating your own strategy and not getting lured in by claims that seem too good to be true. Having an exit plan for any trade you get into can also help to protect profits and limit losses.
How to know if a market is manipulated? ›
Example of Market Manipulation
The buy orders were placed at a price higher than the previous traded price. Therefore, the manipulated orders increased the company's share price and resulted in misleading the investors.
How do you regain market dominance? ›
What can a company do if its market share has been eroded to competitors? There are three key strategies that companies often use to regain market share once it has been lost: pricing changes, promotional changes, and product changes. All three strategies have unique benefits and all are risky for different reasons.
